Man Cares About a Woman Who Doesn’t Care Back
Dear Neil: I am a 29 year old man who has never had a serious relationship. Expressing my feelings for other people has never been one of my strong points. About six months ago, I became very good friends with a woman I work with. She is 42 and divorced, with two teenage children. She divorced four years ago and has been in two bad relationships since. We have talked endlessly on the phone and sometimes in person, but we have never formally dated.
Since I met this lady, my feelings for her have grown from friendship to love. I think about her constantly, and believe that she is the most beautiful woman I have ever met. The problem is that she does not feel as strongly about me. There is an invisible wall up between us, and I’m afraid someone else is going to come along and take her away. I don’t know what else to do.
Please Help
Kentucky
Dear Please Help: It may be that the age difference between the two of you is too much for her. It could be that she just doesn’t find you her type, or it’s possible that she’s feeling burned out on men and wishes to take a break from being in a relationship for the time being.
But regardless of her reasons, if you want a romantic relationship with her, you’re going to have to ask her directly and specifically what it would take for her to take down her wall and give you a chance. You’re going to have to tell her how you feel and what you’re hoping for, and then see if she opens toward you. I she does, invite her out–and behave as a male, not just as a friend. I am not implying that you should be inappropriate or boorish, just that if you are going to convert a friendship to a romantic relationship, you need to take the romantic lead.
If her answer remains “no,” let her go. Few things hurt as much as wanting someone who doesn’t want you back.
Dear Neil: I’ve been in my second marriage for five years. But I married a stranger! All the qualities I thought my husband had before our wedding don’t exist. When we were courting, my husband pretended to be what he thought I wanted, and he put on a great act. Six weeks after our wedding, I started to realize that all the good qualities I thought he had–weren’t there. I have struggled to make our marriage work over the last five years, not willing to admit that I failed again in marriage. Is there anything else I can do to save my marriage?
Bev
Christchurch, New Zealand
Dear Bev: Perhaps. You can start by being very honest and tell him how you are feeling, and specifically what it is you want differently.
If you want him to change his personality, or to have traits he doesn’t have, you are going to fail, because he’s not going change who he is for you. But if you want specific and concrete changes in his behavior, that may be attainable. Be sure to convey to him your sense of dissatisfaction, and be clear about how urgent these changes need to be for you.
Contact Us
Neil Rosenthal
Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist
Relationship Expert
- 303-758-8777
Article Categories
- Relationship Problems Conflicts or Challenges (357)
- Abusiveness (6)
- Ambivalence (3)
- Anger (20)
- Are You Too Needy? (1)
- Borderline Personality Disorder (2)
- Boundaries (4)
- Co-Dependency (3)
- Commitment (33)
- Complainers (1)
- Control / Power Struggles (33)
- Defensiveness (15)
- Disconnection (13)
- Drama Queens (1)
- Emotionally Distant (43)
- Entitlement (2)
- Expectations (2)
- Fighting (3)
- Games Couples Play (1)
- Getting More Support (2)
- Hidden Issues (10)
- Infidelity (38)
- Internet Porn (2)
- Jealousy (9)
- Long Distance Relationships (2)
- Men and Women: Gender Differences in Relationships (21)
- Midlife Crisis (2)
- Money Issues (7)
- Narcissism (9)
- Not Being A Priority (5)
- Psychological Divorce (1)
- Sabotaging a Relationship (47)
- Safety (2)
- Sex / Sexual Issues (52)
- Troubled Loved Ones (3)
- Trust and Betrayal (43)
- Verbal Abuse (7)
- Volatile Relationships (1)
- When am I Good Enough? (1)
- Withdrawal (3)
- Improving Your Relationship (165)
- Apologizing (1)
- Communication (25)
- Compatability (4)
- Conflict Resolution (21)
- Forgiving (18)
- Getting Your Needs Met in Your Relationship (3)
- How To Deepen A Relationship (8)
- Love (24)
- Nurturance (1)
- Reconnecting (6)
- Romance (32)
- Romantic Intelligence (10)
- Seduction-Spark-Passion (6)
- Soulmates (2)
- Spiritual Intimacy (2)
- Traits of Happy Relationships (17)
- Troubleshooting a relationship/Evaluating a Partner (82)
- Improving Yourself (142)
- Christmas Blues (2)
- Dealing With Fears (2)
- Depression (8)
- Emotional Intelligence (6)
- Facing Our Challenges (4)
- Fear of Risking (7)
- Feeling Worthy of Love (2)
- Flourishing (3)
- Happiness (21)
- Inner Critic (8)
- Integrity (5)
- Keep Your New Year_s Resolutions (1)
- Making Peace with the Past (21)
- Maturity (2)
- Memories that won_t go away (2)
- Mistakes (2)
- Owning Your Shadow (3)
- Regeneration (4)
- Regrets (3)
- Resilience (8)
- Self Esteem (33)
- Shame (6)
- Trauma (4)
- Vulnerabilities (2)
- Work (1)
- Worrying (2)
- Looking for a Relationship (45)
- Dating / Singles Issues (35)
- Loneliness (3)
- Looking To Remarry (6)
- Social Media (1)
- Losing a Relationship (42)
- Attachment (4)
- Breaking Up, Closure, Loss and Grieving (26)
- Rejection (13)
- Family Relationships/Parenting (30)
- Adoption (2)
- Defiant Child (1)
- Emotional Emancipation (2)
- Family Estrangements (7)
- Gay/Lesbian Relationships (1)
- In-Laws (2)
- Parenting (17)
- Siblings (1)
Featured Articles
How Important Am I to You? You Have to Show Me.
Dear Neil: I’ve been married for 37 years. My husband no longer notices me. For Christmas, he bought me a book I’d already read, the same ...read more
How it Might be Possible to Win Back Trust
Dear Neil: My fiancé has cheated on me our entire 3 year relationship, having been faithful for perhaps 2 months in that 3 year period. He proposed ...read more
Rules for Women in a Committed Relationship
Dear Neil: I was wondering if you have a Wife 101 column to go with your Husbandry 101 column. What are the equivalent rules for women? Committed ...read more
Husbandry 101: For Committed Men
Dear Neil: I have saved a column you wrote over a decade ago called “Husbandry 101: For Committed Men.” My copy has yellowed and frayed over the ...read more
How to Strengthen Your Relationship
Over the course of my career as a marriage counselor, I have heard thousands of stories about intimate relationships that have gone wrong.
Love, ...read more
Quiz: How Empathetic Are You?
Empathy is the ability to feel the emotions of someone else. It describes how well we identify with other people’s pain, fears, desires, feelings ...read more
The Only Way to Affair-Proof Your Relationship
We know that for the past 30 or so years, the divorce rate has been stuck between 40 and 50 percent of marriages. We also know that some people who ...read more
Finding Your Voice
Dear Neil: My boyfriend and I have been dating for several months. I am in my 20′s, and am in university. He’s moving at the end of next ...read more
How To Tell When He’s Not That Into You
Dear Neil: I don’t know how to start, but I am ever so desperate. I have fallen in love with a man who is 30 (I am 20), and we have been on and ...read more
How to Destroy Your Relationship
Through the years as a marriage therapist, I have been asked a countless number of times: “We were so wild about each other. So much in ...read more